First Majestic Silver vs Agnico Eagle Mines: why the prices moved differently

Weekly · monthly · quarterly news summaries, side by side in time

First Majestic Silver Corp (AG)

Q3 202622 Jun – 31 Jul 2026

▲3▼1

Silver crash hits AG, but output growth and asset sale build value

Silver price collapse pressures revenue Silver fell below $60 an ounce, down over 50% from January's record high, driven by a stronger dollar and rising Treasury yields. This directly lowers the price First Majestic receives for its silver, squeezing revenue and profits, and is the main reason AG shares have dropped.
The silver price crash is the dominant force pushing AG's stock down this period.
Raised 2026 production guidance and larger capital plan First Majestic increased its 2026 production outlook after strong Q2 output and backed it with a US$318–344 million capital program, including the Jerritt Canyon restart and new underground access. More production means more silver and gold to sell, supporting future revenue even at lower prices.
Higher production guidance is a key company-specific catalyst that can offset lower silver prices.
Del Toro mine sale monetizes asset and gains equity stake First Majestic sold its Del Toro silver mine for up to US$60 million and now holds about 24.77% of Sierra Madre's shares. This brings in cash and gives AG exposure to future upside from the mine without operating it, strengthening the balance sheet.
The completed sale is a new capital event that improves AG's financial position.
New permits and drilling extend Santa Elena mine life First Majestic received permits to build the Santo Niño and Navidad portals at Santa Elena and will invest $12 million in 2026. Drilling shows high-grade silver and gold, which could add new mining areas and extend the mine's life, supporting future production growth.
Permits and drilling progress are new operational developments that underpin long-term supply growth.

July 202622 Jun – 31 Jul 2026

▲3▼1

Silver crash hits AG, but output growth and asset sale build value

Silver price collapse pressures revenue Silver fell below $60 an ounce, down over 50% from January's record high, driven by a stronger dollar and rising Treasury yields. This directly lowers the price First Majestic receives for its silver, squeezing revenue and profits, and is the main reason AG shares have dropped.
The silver price crash is the dominant force pushing AG's stock down this period.
Raised 2026 production guidance and larger capital plan First Majestic increased its 2026 production outlook after strong Q2 output and backed it with a US$318–344 million capital program, including the Jerritt Canyon restart and new underground access. More production means more silver and gold to sell, supporting future revenue even at lower prices.
Higher production guidance is a key company-specific catalyst that can offset lower silver prices.
Del Toro mine sale monetizes asset and gains equity stake First Majestic sold its Del Toro silver mine for up to US$60 million and now holds about 24.77% of Sierra Madre's shares. This brings in cash and gives AG exposure to future upside from the mine without operating it, strengthening the balance sheet.
The completed sale is a new capital event that improves AG's financial position.
New permits and drilling extend Santa Elena mine life First Majestic received permits to build the Santo Niño and Navidad portals at Santa Elena and will invest $12 million in 2026. Drilling shows high-grade silver and gold, which could add new mining areas and extend the mine's life, supporting future production growth.
Permits and drilling progress are new operational developments that underpin long-term supply growth.

Latest22 Jun – 31 Jul 2026

▲3▼1

Silver crash hits AG, but output growth and asset sale build value

Silver price collapse pressures revenue Silver fell below $60 an ounce, down over 50% from January's record high, driven by a stronger dollar and rising Treasury yields. This directly lowers the price First Majestic receives for its silver, squeezing revenue and profits, and is the main reason AG shares have dropped.
The silver price crash is the dominant force pushing AG's stock down this period.
Raised 2026 production guidance and larger capital plan First Majestic increased its 2026 production outlook after strong Q2 output and backed it with a US$318–344 million capital program, including the Jerritt Canyon restart and new underground access. More production means more silver and gold to sell, supporting future revenue even at lower prices.
Higher production guidance is a key company-specific catalyst that can offset lower silver prices.
Del Toro mine sale monetizes asset and gains equity stake First Majestic sold its Del Toro silver mine for up to US$60 million and now holds about 24.77% of Sierra Madre's shares. This brings in cash and gives AG exposure to future upside from the mine without operating it, strengthening the balance sheet.
The completed sale is a new capital event that improves AG's financial position.
New permits and drilling extend Santa Elena mine life First Majestic received permits to build the Santo Niño and Navidad portals at Santa Elena and will invest $12 million in 2026. Drilling shows high-grade silver and gold, which could add new mining areas and extend the mine's life, supporting future production growth.
Permits and drilling progress are new operational developments that underpin long-term supply growth.

Agnico Eagle Mines Limited (AEM)

Q3 202611 Jul – 9 Sep 2026

▲2▼1

Record cash flow and gold surge lift AEM, but output risks persist

Record free cash flow and shareholder returns Agnico Eagle generated record free cash flow of $1.34 billion and net income of $1.6 billion, returning $625 million to shareholders. This strong financial performance boosts investor confidence and supports the stock price.
This point highlights the company's strong financial results, a key driver of the stock's performance in the quarter.
Gold price surge and dollar weakness Gold surged above $4,400 per ounce, and Treasury buybacks weakened the dollar, lifting AEM shares by 18.4% in a week. Higher gold prices directly increase Agnico Eagle's revenue and profitability.
This point explains a major external factor that positively impacted AEM's stock price during the quarter.
Production shortfall and capex increase A rock movement at the Barnat pit left 370,000 ounces of gold inaccessible until late 2026, pushing output to the low end of guidance. Capex guidance rose to $2.6–2.8 billion, weighing on the stock.
This point addresses operational challenges that negatively affected production and costs, impacting investor sentiment.
Analyst downgrades and strategic divestments Analysts cut 2026 earnings estimates by ~10% on softer gold, and the stock carried a Strong Sell rating. However, AEM sold Delta and Helm Bay to Vizsla and secured green-power financing at Hope Bay, mitigating risks.
This point captures both negative analyst sentiment and positive strategic actions that balanced the overall outlook.

August 202616 Aug – 9 Sep 2026

▲3▼1

Gold's surge lifts AEM, but rising costs and a pit setback weigh

Gold price surge lifts miners to decade highs Gold broke above $4,400 an ounce, pushing the gold miners ETF to a decade high. Agnico Eagle generated $1.3 billion in quarterly free cash flow, and miners typically move about twice as much as gold. Higher gold means more revenue and cash for AEM.
Gold price is the single biggest force behind AEM's revenue and cash flow.
Treasury buyback weakens dollar, boosting gold The U.S. Treasury doubled its long-dated bond buybacks, weakening the dollar and lifting precious metals. Gold rose over 6% in a week, and Agnico Eagle jumped 18.4% that week. A weaker dollar makes gold cheaper for foreign buyers, supporting demand and AEM's price.
This monetary policy shift directly drove gold and AEM higher during the period.
Costs rise and Barnat pit setback hits output Agnico Eagle raised full-year capex guidance to $2.6-2.8 billion and said a rock movement at the Barnat pit will push production to the low end of guidance, with 370,000 ounces inaccessible until late 2026. Analysts cut estimates, and the stock was downgraded to Strong Sell.
This is the main counterweight: higher costs and lower output pressure AEM's price.
AEM trims risk with project sale and green power Agnico Eagle sold its Delta and Helm Bay projects to Vizsla for about C$32 million in shares, warrants, and royalties, plus up to C$20 million in milestone payments. It also secured a $20 million loan for a wind project at Hope Bay, cutting diesel use and emissions.
These moves free up capital and lower operating costs, supporting AEM's value.

Latest16 Aug – 9 Sep 2026

▲3▼1

Gold's surge lifts AEM, but rising costs and a pit setback weigh

Gold price surge lifts miners to decade highs Gold broke above $4,400 an ounce, pushing the gold miners ETF to a decade high. Agnico Eagle generated $1.3 billion in quarterly free cash flow, and miners typically move about twice as much as gold. Higher gold means more revenue and cash for AEM.
Gold price is the single biggest force behind AEM's revenue and cash flow.
Treasury buyback weakens dollar, boosting gold The U.S. Treasury doubled its long-dated bond buybacks, weakening the dollar and lifting precious metals. Gold rose over 6% in a week, and Agnico Eagle jumped 18.4% that week. A weaker dollar makes gold cheaper for foreign buyers, supporting demand and AEM's price.
This monetary policy shift directly drove gold and AEM higher during the period.
Costs rise and Barnat pit setback hits output Agnico Eagle raised full-year capex guidance to $2.6-2.8 billion and said a rock movement at the Barnat pit will push production to the low end of guidance, with 370,000 ounces inaccessible until late 2026. Analysts cut estimates, and the stock was downgraded to Strong Sell.
This is the main counterweight: higher costs and lower output pressure AEM's price.
AEM trims risk with project sale and green power Agnico Eagle sold its Delta and Helm Bay projects to Vizsla for about C$32 million in shares, warrants, and royalties, plus up to C$20 million in milestone payments. It also secured a $20 million loan for a wind project at Hope Bay, cutting diesel use and emissions.
These moves free up capital and lower operating costs, supporting AEM's value.

July 202611 Jul – 7 Aug 2026

▲2▼1

Record cash flow and growth plans outweigh Barnat setback

Analyst earnings cuts on softer gold prices Before results, analysts slashed 2026 earnings estimates about 10% as gold pulled back from highs, and the stock carried a Strong Sell rating. Lower expected profits make the shares look less attractive, pushing the price down.
It shows a real counterweight — weaker gold prices dragging profit expectations.
Record free cash flow and upgraded credit rating Agnico Eagle posted record quarterly free cash flow of $1.34 billion, net income of $1.6 billion, and returned $625 million to shareholders, while Fitch upgraded its credit rating to A-. Strong cash generation and a solid balance sheet support the stock.
This is the biggest new positive — proof the business is throwing off huge cash.
Organic growth path and gold price rally Management outlined 20-30% production growth over 5-10 years through Detour Lake, Odyssey, and Hope Bay. Meanwhile, easing U.S.-Iran tensions lifted gold prices, and AEM jumped 9.6% in a day as miners rallied on blowout earnings.
It captures the forward growth story plus the gold-price tailwind driving the recent rally.

11 Jul – 7 Aug 2026

▲2▼1

Record cash flow and growth plans outweigh Barnat setback

Analyst earnings cuts on softer gold prices Before results, analysts slashed 2026 earnings estimates about 10% as gold pulled back from highs, and the stock carried a Strong Sell rating. Lower expected profits make the shares look less attractive, pushing the price down.
It shows a real counterweight — weaker gold prices dragging profit expectations.
Record free cash flow and upgraded credit rating Agnico Eagle posted record quarterly free cash flow of $1.34 billion, net income of $1.6 billion, and returned $625 million to shareholders, while Fitch upgraded its credit rating to A-. Strong cash generation and a solid balance sheet support the stock.
This is the biggest new positive — proof the business is throwing off huge cash.
Organic growth path and gold price rally Management outlined 20-30% production growth over 5-10 years through Detour Lake, Odyssey, and Hope Bay. Meanwhile, easing U.S.-Iran tensions lifted gold prices, and AEM jumped 9.6% in a day as miners rallied on blowout earnings.
It captures the forward growth story plus the gold-price tailwind driving the recent rally.

Q2 202620 Jun – 10 Jul 2026

▲2▼1

Gold price swings and Barnat pit setback drive AEM's mixed outlook

Gold price surge on US-Iran peace deal Gold jumped over 6% to above $4,300 an ounce after a preliminary US-Iran peace deal eased inflation and rate fears. Higher gold prices directly boost Agnico Eagle's revenue and profits, making the stock more attractive.
This event directly lifts gold prices, a key driver of AEM's earnings and stock price.
Agnico Eagle completes Rupert Resources acquisition and adds Prism royalty Agnico Eagle finished buying Rupert Resources and acquired a royalty from Prism Resources, expanding its project pipeline in safe regions. This adds long-term growth potential and diversifies its asset mix, supporting future production and cash flow.
This acquisition expands AEM's future growth prospects, a fundamental positive for the stock.
Barnat pit wall movement reduces production A rock slide at the Barnat pit in Quebec temporarily halted mining. Agnico Eagle expects to lose 60,000-80,000 ounces of gold production in the second half of 2026, with potential annual reductions of up to 150,000 ounces in 2027 and 2028. This lowers near-term output and weighs on the stock.
This is a new operational setback that directly cuts production and hurts earnings.
Valuation debate: undervalued vs. gold price retreat One analysis says Agnico Eagle is 29% undervalued based on cash flow, but another notes the stock fell 31% in three months as gold prices dropped from near $5,600 to below $4,000. The market is torn between long-term value and recent price weakness.
This captures the current tug-of-war affecting AEM's price, balancing optimism and recent declines.

June 202620 Jun – 10 Jul 2026

▲2▼1

Gold price swings and Barnat pit setback drive AEM's mixed outlook

Gold price surge on US-Iran peace deal Gold jumped over 6% to above $4,300 an ounce after a preliminary US-Iran peace deal eased inflation and rate fears. Higher gold prices directly boost Agnico Eagle's revenue and profits, making the stock more attractive.
This event directly lifts gold prices, a key driver of AEM's earnings and stock price.
Agnico Eagle completes Rupert Resources acquisition and adds Prism royalty Agnico Eagle finished buying Rupert Resources and acquired a royalty from Prism Resources, expanding its project pipeline in safe regions. This adds long-term growth potential and diversifies its asset mix, supporting future production and cash flow.
This acquisition expands AEM's future growth prospects, a fundamental positive for the stock.
Barnat pit wall movement reduces production A rock slide at the Barnat pit in Quebec temporarily halted mining. Agnico Eagle expects to lose 60,000-80,000 ounces of gold production in the second half of 2026, with potential annual reductions of up to 150,000 ounces in 2027 and 2028. This lowers near-term output and weighs on the stock.
This is a new operational setback that directly cuts production and hurts earnings.
Valuation debate: undervalued vs. gold price retreat One analysis says Agnico Eagle is 29% undervalued based on cash flow, but another notes the stock fell 31% in three months as gold prices dropped from near $5,600 to below $4,000. The market is torn between long-term value and recent price weakness.
This captures the current tug-of-war affecting AEM's price, balancing optimism and recent declines.

20 Jun – 10 Jul 2026

▲2▼1

Gold price swings and Barnat pit setback drive AEM's mixed outlook

Gold price surge on US-Iran peace deal Gold jumped over 6% to above $4,300 an ounce after a preliminary US-Iran peace deal eased inflation and rate fears. Higher gold prices directly boost Agnico Eagle's revenue and profits, making the stock more attractive.
This event directly lifts gold prices, a key driver of AEM's earnings and stock price.
Agnico Eagle completes Rupert Resources acquisition and adds Prism royalty Agnico Eagle finished buying Rupert Resources and acquired a royalty from Prism Resources, expanding its project pipeline in safe regions. This adds long-term growth potential and diversifies its asset mix, supporting future production and cash flow.
This acquisition expands AEM's future growth prospects, a fundamental positive for the stock.
Barnat pit wall movement reduces production A rock slide at the Barnat pit in Quebec temporarily halted mining. Agnico Eagle expects to lose 60,000-80,000 ounces of gold production in the second half of 2026, with potential annual reductions of up to 150,000 ounces in 2027 and 2028. This lowers near-term output and weighs on the stock.
This is a new operational setback that directly cuts production and hurts earnings.
Valuation debate: undervalued vs. gold price retreat One analysis says Agnico Eagle is 29% undervalued based on cash flow, but another notes the stock fell 31% in three months as gold prices dropped from near $5,600 to below $4,000. The market is torn between long-term value and recent price weakness.
This captures the current tug-of-war affecting AEM's price, balancing optimism and recent declines.